fbpx
Font size: +
3 minutes reading time (583 words)

Obtaining Homeschool Freedom Through Mediation

When the president signed the Basic Education Laws Amendment (BELA) Act on 13 September, contentious Clauses 4 and 5 were put on hold, allowing for a three-month consultation period. On 5 November, Solidarity, the DA, Afriforum, and the Freedom Front held a protest at the Voortrekker monument, in which 10,000 people participated. On 28 November it was announced that a settlement was reached between Solidarity, the Presidency and the Minister of Basic Education on the implementation of Clauses 4 and 5 at the National Economic Development and Labour Council (NEDLAC). This outcome is described as a major victory for civic society over politicians.

NEDLAC is a structure that resolves disputes between organised business, labour and community & development interests as well as the state. Solidarity and other unions are part of organised labour, whereas SGB’s can be viewed as organisations that represent community interests. This made NEDLAC a suitable vehicle to resolve the dispute around Clauses 4 and 5 of the BELA Act.

The dispute about Clause 35 is between parents on the one side and the state on the other hand. Some people view homeschoolers as a community, but the term 'movement' is probably more appropriate, as homeschooling is a collective of individuals from diverse communities who choose home education for different reasons. This makes NEDLAC unsuitable for resolving the dispute about Clause 35.

However, although the NEDLAC structure is unsuitable for resolving the Clause 35 dispute, it does make an important point about the method used for dispute resolution, namely mediation.

Mediation is a method that is increasingly used for dispute resolution, as an alternative to litigation. As the Department of Justice has put it, the advantages of mediation include the following:

  • It offers speedy resolution of disputes. It is considerably cheaper than litigation.
  • It may provide a win-win situation for both parties to a dispute.
  • The process is flexible and avoids technicalities.
  • It is a voluntary process.
  • It promotes reconciliation.

In the home education movement, many put a lot of trust in the Constitution and the Constitutional Court, due to victories achieved through litigation. A notable constitutional judgement that greatly contributed towards freedom in education was the Harris case that determined the policy cannot be enforced.

However, recent books seriously question whether such a trust is always justified. Koos Malan's book, 'There is No Supreme Constitution', explains that the bill of individual rights cannot guarantee justice, because rights are subject to the ideologically-driven exercise of judicial interpretation, often with damaging consequences for those relying on the bill of rights. In the book "The Emperor Has No Clothing", Keith Matthee SC gives evidence that, despite its popularity, the Constitutional Court of South Africa, in its ruling on whether unborn human life is worthy of dignity, has shown that it is an emperor without clothes.

Given the success of mediation in resolving the conflict on Clauses 4 and 5, there is merit in investigating whether there are opportunities to resolve the dispute about Clause 35 by means of mediation. Mediation and litigation have advantages and disadvantages, and these should be carefully considered. The movement should avoid putting their hope in litigation alone.

Unfortunately, the home education movement is fragmented with different views on who should determine what is in the best interests of children. If effort can be put into finding common goals for cooperation, acknowledged structures such as the Joint Liaison Committees and the National Task Team can be used to find a win-win solution for all.

Unity and Division in the Home Education Movement:...

Related Posts

 

Comments

No comments made yet. Be the first to submit a comment
Already Registered? Login Here
Guest
Monday, 09 December 2024

Legal & Research

Research on Home Education

Research on home education consistently proves that home learners

+ View

Homeschooling and the law

Home schooling was recognized in 1996 in the SA Schools Act.

+ View

History of homeschooling in SA

History of home education in South Africa (Wikipedia article)

+ View

Centres

Learning centre overview

Homeschool, micro-school, learning centre, unregistered private

+ View

Start a Learning Centre

Important considerations when starting a learning centre

+ View

Find a learning centre

There are various ways to find learning centres. Since there is

+ View

Homeschool ABC

A

Approaches

Popular homeschooling approaches and styles ...

+ View
B

Beginning

5 Easy steps to start homeschooling ...

+ View
C

Curriculum

How to choose a curriculum for your family ...

+ View

Videos

Support

Homeschool Family blogs

Blogs by homeschooling families that share their experiences and ...

Tutors

Tutors provide additional support to homeschooling parents. ... ...

Support Groups

Forums where parents and learners discuss issues with each other and ...

Assessment Tools

Homeschoolers make use of a variety of formal and informal ...

Curriculums

Pestalozzi Trust

The Pestalozzi Trust is a registered public benefit organisation ...

Comprehendi

Introducing Comprendi™ — the Revolutionary Reading Comprehension ...

A.C.E (Gr R - 12)

    The A.C.E. programme is uniquely suited to home education, ...

Beit HaSefer

  Tailor made Home Education by Beit HaSefer (No ‘one size fits ...

Q & A

Has no content to show!

  • Prev
  • Curriculums & Resources